By Jörg Breuning, The Green Roof Patroller May 31, 2013
The main purpose of an extensive green roof is stormwater retention and delaying stormwater runoff amongst many other added values.
A permanent irrigated extensive Green Roof with sprinklers – most inefficient and most plants' destructive solution. Photo: Jörg Breuning
In the last decade, I've seen many green roofs where the intended plants never really flourished. I estimate that in the US at least 50% of the green roofs are not performing to their fullest potential. This can be observed by simply looking at the most obvious of indicators, the plants themselves, regardless if they were planted on purpose or somehow found the space to take root. Most of these less healthy extensive green roofs are pre-planted boxes, or commonly known as modular systems. Not only are these systems much more costly, in my opinion the mid to long term results are often far below systems that are assembled in place and at the time of installation.
I know that the transition from being a common nursery-grown plant (including pre-planted boxes) to the extreme environment of a rooftop poses severe challenges. Green roof plant nurseries typically have "great" advice and recommend the installation of temporary or, more often, permanent irrigation systems. This advice is defeating the purpose of an extensive green roof and shows that asking self-appointed experts can cause a spiral of failures. Since many green roof installers lack the proper horticultural knowledge, they may not be able to identify problems by simply looking at the indicators. This could cause the problem to gain momentum.
In addition, the false conclusion that technology (Google search, Apps, synthetic growth media or sophisticated soil moisture control devices) can fix the problem supports my theory of less experienced or misinformed green roof professionals. They rely heavily on technology to fix any issue and miss the big picture.
Nature has the ability to take care of itself, as long as the appropriate design, materials and plants are used in addition to being familiar with the immediate climate.
Only 1.73% of all water on earth is usable fresh water (Wikipedia); 70% of this little water is used for irrigation in agricultural/horticultural and it is distributed very unequally on Earth. At this point, it does not matter whether it is a rooftop farm, organic food farm, a conventional farm on the ground, landscaped area or a green roof. Getting the water from the source to irrigation system requires gigantic efforts like super powered pumps, endless piping, canals, dams and sophisticated logistic and politics. The consequences of irrigation can spread from irreparable ecological damages (artificial lakes destroy natural habitat), wars, high carbon footprint and consistently lowering ground water tables (more irrigation is required).
Another major problem of irrigating agricultural/horticultural land is the tremendous impact on the natural water retention of soil: An irrigated area has higher moisture content and consequently less ability to retain water. For example, the runoff from agricultural/horticultural land is the leading source of impairments to surveyed rivers and lakes (EPA).
Farm Runoff in Mississippi River Floodwater Fuels Dead Zone in the Gulf of Mexico; via pbs.org.
This is evidence enough that commercial growers (farmers –especially for bio-fuels, nurseries), LEED™ experts or green roof professionals who utilize irrigation might not have the right approach to farming, landscape design or modern green roof technology for extensive green roofs.
Rain-fed farms or so called dry farms can reduce water consumption on the commercial grower side but green roof designers also need to understand that any commercial production of a crop is done with the intention of selling it in the shortest time as possible.
An owner of an extensive green roof, however, wants to keep his “crop” as long as possible – actually never wants to sell it, investing the least maintenance with it. What a conflict of interest and all the experts and academics in the North American green roof industry haven’t that found out yet. Vice versa if you ask them for advice - you might not get the answer you are looking for.
Green roof designers and green roof professionals must understand that less technology is often more when it comes to extensive green roofs and that no building owner wants to irrigate the roof in short, mid or long terms. In my opinion, there is no need to make a green roof more complicated (and water needy) by using multiple synthetic or plastic layers. LEED™ certification supports using gray (recycled) water for green roof irrigation or recycled components that are not needed; they missed the point of an extensive green roof system retaining as much stormwater as possible.
Common sense is understanding the main purpose of extensive green roofs, the problems that come with irrigation, and environmental awareness combined with extensive horticultural experience. These are the only things that will aid in planning the perfect green roof.
Above: Un-irrigated self-established Green Roof in arid climate zone (might need some structural support!); Photo: Jörg Breuning
Implementing irrigation on an extensive green roof is a clear sign of not understanding the basic principles of horticultural techniques or the laws of nature. Irrigation reduces the water retention, increases the nutrient pollution in runoff and requires higher fertilization application. Irrigated extensive green roofs are not environmentally friendly, not economically feasible and have hardly any payback for the building owner if the true costs of water are considered.
I tell my clients if they have an offer or design for an extensive green roof that includes irrigation - be cautious!
Jörg was born in the green roof capital of world. He began working with green roofs in Stuttgart, Germany in 1980. Since then, he has installed and maintained tens of millions of square feet of green roofs throughout the world. Remember, everyone, that English is not his mother tongue!
During his career Jörg has earned multiple degrees and certifications in landscaping, horticultural, and green roofing. In January 1983, Jörg Breuning was one of the first people in the world to earn a green roof professional accreditation from Optima, now Optigrün AG, who were the first green roof manufacturer to offer an in depth educational system for the installation and maintenance of their products. In order to be eligible for the accreditation, a candidate had to have completed 3-years of apprenticeship with a certified landscaping company. In 1985 he earned his national certification and horticultural technician degree – a program of work and study that required 5-years of practice in an approved landscaping company and 4 semesters of University study.
In 2003 Jörg transferred his German Company (founded in 1985) to the United States after being the key consultant for Chicago’s City Hall green roof. As an experienced horticultural expert, he has been able to educate many of North America’s green roof pioneers, providing them with fundamental green roof knowledge to start and grow their own businesses.
His company Green Roof Service LLC (Green Roof Technology) has introduced numerous innovations to the North American green roof industry. Many of these innovations have been adopted by companies such as Roofmeadow, Emory Knoll Farm, GAF, CETCO, Rooflite, Green Roof Solutions, Celebrity Cruises Miami and Optigreen.
Jörg’s articles will strongly focus on topics that ensure common sense is always practiced, ensuring that the horse stays in front of the cart, and provide valuable insights into making green roofs as popular and efficient as they are in Europe.
The opinions expressed by our Guest Feature writers and editors may not necessarily reflect the beliefs of Greenroofs.com, and are offered to our readers to simply present individual views and experiences and open a dialogue of further discussion, debate and research. Enjoy, and if you have a particular comment, please contact the author or send us an email to: firstname.lastname@example.org.